• PBL Design Kit
Menu
  • PBL Design Kit
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Menu
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Search
Close
  • PBL Design Kit
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Menu
  • PBL Design Kit
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Search
Close
04_Critique_RLSF3504_Resized
Play Video

Critique

Learn through analysis, unpacking, and appreciation

RESOURCES

15 Minute Project Tuning Protocol

7 Minute Project Tuning Protocol

Accelerated Project Tuning Protocol

HTH Project Design Kit

Kind Specific and Helpful Critique

Sample Critique Cover Sheet

VIDEO PLAYLIST

Play Video
Ron Berger – Rules For Critique
Play Video
Ron Berger – Constantly Critiquing
Play Video
Ron Berger – Culture of Critique
Play Video
Project Tuning
Play Video
Math Portfolio Critique
Play Video
Critique— Nonfiction Writing in a Project

PRACTICES

Project Launch

Essential Questions

Ideation

Critique

Academic Skills, Content, and Dispositions

Drafting and Revision

Exhibition

Assessment

Reflection

About This Practice:

Students and teachers use structures to analyze work samples for meaning, unpack the principles that contribute to their effectiveness, and identify important learning targets.

Critique structures and protocols promote equitable learning spaces and foster collegial relationships among students and adults. Critique is integrated into the fabric of the school culture as a method to understand, to learn, and to share powerful ideas.

HTH Design Principles

Equity

Shape critique processes to welcome all voices, and guide students to both consider alternative perspectives and to frame their requests for feedback so that they will accomplish their goals. Purposeful critique is vital to deeper learning—the goal is to ensure every student offers and receives it.

Personalization

Orient critique practice towards each student achieving goals that are meaningful to their personal learning. Students select the exemplars that they measure their work against, co-create rubrics, and direct the type of critical feedback that best supports their growth.

Authentic Work

Focus critiques on elements of quality and learning targets found in real-world products meaningful to the students and the project’s stakeholders. Rigorous student critique matches the qualities and practices of professionals or experts, and experts or professionals are rich sources for critique.

Collaborative Design

What perspectives might experts, users, peers, or community members offer? How might they approach a critique, given their experience or expertise? Allow feedback both on teacher-processes and student work Effective critique becomes collaborative decentralized one-on-one instruction.

Subscribe to the GSE Newsletter

SUBSCRIBE
pble gray_PBL Essentials 1
hthgse-footer1.png

Subscribe to the GSE Newsletter

SUBSCRIBE
  • PBL Design Kit
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Menu
  • PBL Design Kit
  • FAQ
  • Contact

SUBSCRIBE

© HIGH TECH HIGH GRADUATE SCHOOL OF EDUCATION 2008 - 2022. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.​